World bank thats where xi is pushing the country in the wrong direction. China, as indicated, finds itself closing in on middleincome trap levels estimated to be at around usd 15,00016,000 while featuring relatively poor institutional quality. Countries that are neither rich nor poor can hold their own against rivals at both extremes. China has grown into an upper middle income economy, but its a still far from joining the higher income club source. Without further institutional development, it risks getting stuck in the middleincome trap. Mixedincome myths the middleincome trap has little. For example, in his speech at the world economic forum in davos 2015, the chinese premier li keqiang mentioned the various reforms china has to undertake in order to successfully overcome the middleincome trap4. How to avoid the middle income trap columns hindustan. Middleincome trap, economy of china, political economy, technological capability, economic development. Introduction since the mid2000s, economists in both academia and development multilaterals have drawn increasing attention to the middle income mi trap, especially in outheast s asia and atin lamerica.
Middle income trap is a situation for middle income countries where they are not able to move up to the higher income status due to the operation of several adverse factors. Escaping the middleincome trap 411 there began earlier than in southeast and south asia and because it was compressed in time. The term middleincome trap mit usually refers to countries that have experienced rapid growth and thus quickly reached middleincome status, but then failed to overcome that income range to further catch up to the developed countries. It argues that the economic woes of the middle east and north. Of 101 middle income economies in 1960, only had graduated to high income hi by 2008 world bank 2012. Growth slowdowns and the middleincome trap international. Recent research suggests that growth past a certain threshold requires a qualitative shift as economies transition from labour and. In an earlier paper eichengreen, park and shin 2012, we analyzed historical experience with growth slowdowns as a way of shedding light on future prospects. Second, conventional wisdom subscribes to the notion of a middleincome trap the idea that when countries reach some intermediate income threshold, growth becomes much more difficult.
Middle income trap, growth strategies, economic growth, economic transitions what is the middle income trap. Xis leading chinas economy into the middleincome trap. The middleincome trap has become a broad designation trying to capture the many cases of developing countries that succeeded in evolving from low to middlelevels of per capita income, but. Gill and homi kharas paper presented at the 37th paftad conference, singapore, june 35, 2015. Malaysia transitioned into what the world bank defines as an uppermiddleincome country in 1979. Mixedincome myths the middleincome trap has little evidence going for it. Both countries have advanced to uppermiddleincome status, per the world banks classification of economies according. Responses to the middleincome trap in china, malaysia. How china can avoid the middle income trap insead knowledge. While there are different possible sources of the trap, khor et al.
The asian economy is expected to realise favourable growth during the first half of this century, but there is no guarantee. We argue, first, that none of the papers referred to above has provided a definition of the middle income trap, much less a theoretical treatment of the phenomenon. If the same growth rate can be maintained until 2020, then one billion people would be living in highincome areas by that time. At its heart, the middleincome trap is a governance failure. Economists who take temporal and geographical context seriously have identified relatively low productivity growth as key to conceptualising the middleincome trap ohno, 2009. The middleincome trap countries that have been subject to the middleincome trap have had very different experiences, as shown in the figure below. Although the range associated with middleincome status differs across studies, they are in general defined in absolute terms. This paper discusses in more detail definitional issues on the socalled middleincome trap.
Growth strategies to avoid the middleincome trap by homi kharas. The middleincome trap is the phenomenon of hitherto rapidly growing economies stagnating at middleincome levels and failing to graduate into the ranks of. Some countriessuch as the asian tigers hong kong, singapore, south korea and taiwan, spain and irelandhave experienced rapid and persistent relative income growth. Will income inequality cause a middleincome trap in asia.
David bloom and jeffrey williamson argue that the demographic dividend explains up to half of the east asian miracle, which they define as growth of per capita incomes in excess of the steadystate rate. We argue, first, that none of the papers referred to above has provided a definition of the middleincome trap, much less a theoretical treatment of the phenomenon. This paper first considers the example of malaysia, which is a typical country facing the middleincome trap suehiro 2014, pp. The middleincome trap 159 contrary to what many growth theories predict, there is no tendency for low and middle income countries to converge toward high income countries figure s6. A middleincome trap could occur not only if there is a delay in shifting the economy toward. Both countries have advanced to uppermiddleincome status, per the world banks classification of economies according to their gross national income gni per capita lower. The middle income trap has come to dominate headlines and policy discussions in the asiapacific. If youre looking for a free download links of law and development of middleincome countries. Of 101 middleincome economies in 1960, only had graduated to high. There is a discussion about a middleincome trap, which refers to a country that has realised rapid growth to become a middleincome country but is unable to grow further. This was the middleincome trap, a favored term of economists at international institutions and in american think tanks.
If the targeted growth rate of the 12th plan is achieved, as is likely, 260 million people will be living in highincome provinces by 2015. Aug 05, 20 at its heart, the middle income trap is a governance failure. The middleincome trap is the phenomenon of hitherto rapidly growing economies stagnating at middle income levels and failing to graduate into the ranks of high income countries. We nd that the concept survives a rigorous scrutiny of the data, with the growth patterns of 19. Apr 12, 2016 china, as indicated, finds itself closing in on middleincome trap levels estimated to be at around usd 15,00016,000 while featuring relatively poor institutional quality. Jun 25, 2019 the middle income trap is a theoretical economic development situation, in which a country that attains a certain income due to given advantages gets stuck at that level. What is the middle income trap, why do countries fall into it. The middleincome trap more politics than economics by richard f. The term middleincome trap, first coined by gill, kharas and others 2007, refers to the possibility that economies could get stuck at a certain level of income. Unheralded and unwanted, it occurs after a newly industrialized economy such as south africa, brazil. In this study we examine the middleincome trap as a special case of growth slowdowns, which are identified as large sudden and sustained deviations from the growth. This paper discusses in more detail definitional issues on the socalled middle income trap.
Our work suggests that any tendency of this type is very weak, and that what is often ascribed to the middleincome trap is better thought of as growth. Although the range associated with middleincome status differs across studies, they. Both countries have advanced to upper middle income status, per the world banks classification of economies according to their gross national income gni per capita lower. The middleincome trap is generally associated with the notion that countries get stuck in a certain range of income distribution and rarely manage to reach highincome status. Middleincome trap world bank documents world bank group. In americas quarterly 5 1, checked on 240120 4 bank indonesia, 20. The nature and avoidance of the middle income trap abstract the middle income trap is a significant theoretical and practical issue closely related to the economic and social transition and sustainable development of a country. The middle income trap results when growth is undercut by the changes it induces, such as east asias lowwage labourled growth undercut by rising wages in response to prosperity. Among those writing on the middleincome trap, most agree on defining it as an extensive period of middleincome limbo, especially in contrast with earlier developers. Pdf this study aims at investigating the phenomena of the middleincome trap found in developing asian countries, such as china, india, indonesia. Predetermined to fall new york university, may 2012. The term middle income trap has entered common parlance in the development policy community, despite the lack of a precise definition.
The term itself often has not been precisely defined in the incipient literature. They understand the middleincome predicament in the. Responses to the middleincome trap in china, malaysia, and. However, very few have made the additional leap needed to become high income economies. The middle income trap exists for some countries that make significant progress in reducing extreme poverty and experience structural change and growth but then find it difficult to make the climb from being a middle income country to achieve high income fullydeveloped status. The recent slowdown in economic growth in china has also revived the debate on what causes middleincome traps and what type of policies can help to avoid. Why do countries fall into it, and how can it be avoided. Nov 30, 2016 the term middle income trap mit usually refers to countries that have experienced rapid growth and thus quickly reached middle income status, but then failed to overcome that income range to further catch up to the developed countries. In recent years, the term middle income trap has entered common parlance in the development policy community. Economists call it the middleincome trap, and they say that it happens on every continent. The term mit usually refers to countries that have experienced rapid growth and thus reached the status of a middleincome country mic in a very short period of time, but have not been able to further catch up with the group of highincome economies. E0,f0,n1 abstract we analyze the incidence and correlates of growth slowdowns in fastgrowing middle income countries. We see five major types of middleincome trap to which china is vulnerable. Recently, countries experiencing growth stagnation at middle income levels, a condition gill and kharas 2007 termed the middle bm.
The middleincome trap is the phenomenon of hitherto rapidly growing economies stagnating at middleincome levels and failing to graduate into the ranks of highincome countries. The middle income trap exists for some countries that make significant progress in reducing extreme poverty and experience structural change and growth but then find it difficult to make the climb from being a middleincome country to achieve highincome fullydeveloped status. We draw satisfaction from the fact that some of our previous writings gill and kharas, 2008. Africa offer new insights into the debate on the trap which has thus far focused on the east asia and. Indermit gill is the director for development policy in the office of the chief economist of the world bank. The middleincome trap 159 contrary to what many growth theories predict, there is no tendency for low and middleincome countries to converge toward highincome countries figure s6. In recent years, policymakers in slowergrowing middleincome countries have become preoccupied with the notion that they are stuck in a middleincome trap. The term middle income trap is by now also being widely used in economic literature as well as businessoriented media. This paper discusses in more detail the definitional issues associated with the term. Starting around the end of the 2000s, a certain term was often used in discussions about emerging asian countries. Technology adoption and the middleincome trap world bank.
Middle income trap and its causes in india upsc ias. The analysis indicates that, in 2010, 35 out of the 52 middleincome countries were in the middleincome trap, 30 in the lowermiddleincome trap 9 of them can potentially graduate. New evidence on the middle income trap barry eichengreen, donghyun park, and kwanho shin nber working paper no. Escaping the middle income trap 411 there began earlier than in southeast and south asia and because it was compressed in time. If the targeted growth rate of the 12th plan is achieved, as is likely, 260 million people will be living in high income provinces by 2015. The term middleincome trap has entered common parlance in the development policy community, despite the lack of a precise definition. Dec 11, 2014 second, conventional wisdom subscribes to the notion of a middleincome trap the idea that when countries reach some intermediate income threshold, growth becomes much more difficult. Dec 17, 2018 future development how to avoid the middle income trap. Among those writing on the middle income trap, most agree on defining it as an extensive period of middle income limbo, especially in contrast with earlier developers. If the same growth rate can be maintained until 2020, then one billion people would be living in high income areas by that time. Since we coined the term in 2006, the middle income trap has been. It begins by laying out different approaches to defining the mit and by presenting as well as classifying the most. Avoiding the middleincome trap pdf, epub, docx and torrent then this site is not for you. Jan, 2019 china has grown into an upper middle income economy, but its a still far from joining the higher income club source.
Unable to compete with either lowwage economies or highly skilled advanced economies the development economics literature has advanced the notion of a poverty trap gill and kharas, 2008. For example, in his speech at the world economic forum in davos 2015, the chinese premier li keqiang mentioned the various reforms china has to undertake in order to. In our view, the absence of such a theory reflects the neglect of the political economy bases of the middleincome trap. Recently, countries experiencing growth stagnation at middleincome levels, a condition gill and kharas 2007 termed the middle bm. Since we introduced the term middleincome trap in 2006, it has become popular among policy makers and researchers. Prepared by shekhar aiyar, romain duval, damien puy, yiqun wu, and longmei. The country is weak in human capital in terms of health and education. They imply that a country that becomes lowermiddleincome i. Rather, many have gotten stuck in what has been called a middle income trap or more appropriately perhaps, an imitation trap, as discussed latercharacterized by a sharp deceleration in growth. The middle income trap is an economic development situation in which a country that attains a certain income due to given advantages gets stuck at that level. Homi kharas is senior fellow at the brookings institution. Future development how to avoid the middleincome trap.
The cui shows that china became a middleincome country in 20072008. Rather, many have gotten stuck in what has been called a middleincome trapor more appropriately perhaps, an imitation trap, as discussed latercharacterized by a sharp deceleration in growth. To understand middle income trap, classification of countries by the world bank in terms of percapita income is to be understood. Gdp growth rates often slow down and a country can struggle to. The middle income trap is a theoretical economic development situation, in which a country that attains a certain income due to given advantages gets stuck at that level. Unheralded and unwanted, it occurs after a newly industrialized economy such as. Introduction since the mid2000s, economists in both academia and development multilaterals have drawn increasing attention to the middleincome mi trap, especially in outheast s asia and atin lamerica. The peoples republic of china in the middleincome trap.
574 483 580 6 998 1142 647 223 619 259 24 727 1419 351 907 144 823 1079 1480 1388 453 745 985 143 216 440 1373 799 1295 622 252 781 800 590 1534 272 351 514 21 588 242 146 854 1234 1139 999